For millions of people, working when everyone else is asleep is simply part of the job. From nurses and doctors to emergency service workers, pilots, cabin crew and factory staff, night shifts and irregular working hours are a reality of modern life. In the UAE and wider region, where international aviation is such an important industry, irregular schedules, overnight flights and crossing multiple time zones create particular challenges for flight crews.
But while many people accept tiredness as an inevitable consequence of shift work, persistent sleep problems can sometimes point to something more serious: shift work disorder.
I believe this is an important and often overlooked area of sleep medicine. A systematic review and meta-analysis published in 2021, examining 29 studies involving more than 22,000 workers, estimated that around 26.5% of shift workers experience the condition. That is approximately one in four.
Despite how common it appears to be, shift work disorder often goes unrecognised. Many people simply put up with excessive sleepiness, difficulty falling asleep or feeling exhausted despite spending enough time in bed, assuming it is something they have to accept because of their job.
But chronic sleep disruption should not be dismissed as an inevitable part of working shifts. It is a condition that can be recognised, assessed and managed.
Why shift work disrupts your body clock
Our bodies are naturally programmed to sleep at night and remain awake during the day. This internal timing system, known as the circadian rhythm, regulates our sleep-wake cycle and influences everything from hormone production and body temperature to alertness and metabolism.
When we work through the night and try to sleep during daylight hours, we are effectively asking our bodies to work against their natural rhythms.
One of the biggest challenges I see is that the body does not necessarily adapt to the hours we ask it to keep. Even if someone has worked nights for years, their internal body clock may still be telling them to sleep when they need to be awake and become alert when they are trying to rest.
This mismatch can lead to difficulty sleeping after a shift, excessive sleepiness at work, poor concentration and persistent fatigue.
I think it is important to recognise that this is not simply a case of being tired after a long night. Shift work disorder is a sleep-wake condition associated with working hours that can have a significant impact on everyday functioning, health and safety. Too many workers regard persistent sleepiness or difficulty sleeping as an unavoidable consequence of their jobs, rather than something that can be addressed.
What do the new guidelines recommend?
The new clinical practice guidelines from the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) offer some welcome direction for people struggling with shift work disorder. What I find particularly important is that they recognise treatment needs to be tailored to the individual. Someone struggling to stay awake during a night shift has a very different problem from someone who cannot sleep after finishing work. A single approach is unlikely to work for everyone.
For people who struggle to stay awake during night shifts, medications such as modafinil and armodafinil are among the better-supported options. They can improve alertness and help people function during working hours.
However, it is important to understand the distinction between helping someone stay awake and correcting the underlying sleep problem. These medications do not reset the body clock or replace the need for adequate sleep. They can also cause side effects, including headaches, nausea, dizziness and anxiety.
I would also like to see more research into their long-term effects and, importantly, whether improved alertness translates into fewer workplace or driving accidents.
For those whose biggest challenge is falling asleep after finishing a shift, a different approach may be needed. The new guidelines also recognise a group of medications known as dual orexin receptor antagonists (DORAs). These work by blocking orexin, a brain chemical that plays an important role in keeping us awake. By reducing this wakefulness signal, they can help people fall asleep and stay asleep.
There are three medications in this class: suvorexant (Belsomra), lemborexant (Dayvigo) and daridorexant (Quviviq). They are prescription treatments for insomnia and may be considered in selected patients experiencing sleep difficulties associated with shift work disorder.
However, the evidence specifically relating to shift work disorder remains limited. The AASM recommendation is conditional, with the available evidence largely based on research involving suvorexant. We should not assume that all three medications have been equally studied in shift workers.
Why your shift pattern matters
Another important aspect of the new guidelines is the recognition that treatment needs to reflect the type of shifts someone works.
For people working permanent nights, carefully timed exposure to bright light and maintaining a consistent daytime sleep schedule may help the body clock adjust, at least partially. The aim is to encourage the body to adapt to a more consistent pattern of wakefulness and sleep.
For those working rotating shifts, however, things are more complicated. Constantly trying to reset the body’s internal clock as working hours change may be impractical and potentially counterproductive.
In these cases, I believe the priority should be managing symptoms and protecting opportunities for adequate sleep, rather than repeatedly trying to reset the body clock.
This is why there is no universal solution. What works for a nurse working three consecutive night shifts may not be appropriate for a pilot operating long-haul flights across multiple time zones or someone alternating between early starts, late finishes and overnight work.
Understanding an individual’s schedule and symptoms is essential when deciding on the most appropriate treatment.
Aviation and medication restrictions
This is particularly relevant to pilots and cabin crew, an important workforce in the UAE and wider region. Flight crews operate in an exceptionally safety-sensitive environment, where even a relatively small impairment in alertness or reaction time could have serious consequences. The use of sedating prescription medications, including DORAs, therefore raises additional considerations around fitness to fly.
Aviation medical regulations place strict requirements on medication use, and pilots and cabin crew must follow the guidance of their aviation medical examiner and relevant aviation authority. In many circumstances, medications with potential sedative effects may be incompatible with flying duties. This is entirely understandable given the responsibility flight crews have for passenger and operational safety.
For this group, managing sleep disruption through appropriate scheduling, sleep protection, circadian strategies and specialist assessment is particularly important. No one should start or stop medication in order to manage shift work without first seeking appropriate medical and aeromedical advice.
A step forward, but more research is needed
I welcome the new guidelines because they provide clinicians with a clearer framework for assessing and treating shift work disorder. They also help move the conversation away from the idea that chronic exhaustion is simply part of working unsociable hours.
That said, I would emphasise that all the recommendations are conditional, reflecting limitations in the quality and quantity of the available evidence. These guidelines are a useful step forward, but they are not a one-size-fits-all solution.
We need more research into treatments that provide lasting benefits and improve both health and workplace safety. In particular, I would like to see more evidence about which treatments work best for different shift patterns, whether their benefits are sustained over time and whether improving alertness can genuinely reduce the risk of accidents.
For anyone regularly struggling to stay awake at work, sleeping during the day or feeling exhausted despite having enough opportunity to rest, my advice is not to automatically put it down to the job.
Shift work disorder is a recognised sleep condition, and there are ways to manage it. The first step is recognising that persistent sleep disruption is not something you necessarily have to accept.
Read the full article on Medical News Today: https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/how-can-people-manage-shift-work-disorder-new-guidelines-offer-advice#Which-treatments-do-the-new-guidelines-recommend